” … we must not regard what is obsolete to us as something obsolete to a class, to the masses.” Lenin, Left Wing Communism: an Infantile Disorder

Any political mapping of the vast majority of people would tell us that they don’t neatly or consistently fit into the categories of left or socialist, even progressive. Where then are they found? It depends on the issue, prevailing moods in the country, and who best frames the issue.

If that is the case, isn’t the challenge to find a demand or position that they will embrace and, in doing so, to move the political conversation and needle in a democratic, progressive, or left direction, even if it falls short of what you think is needed at that moment. In other words, the challenge is to convince and move people from where they are, in a language that they understand and corresponds with their experience to a different position that isn’t necessarily yours, but closer to yours.

And it may well set in motion (or, at least bring into the conversation) further shifts that more closely approximate your political position on one or another issue. Politics in this sense is more an art that takes into account what others think and their experience on the one hand and less a declaration of your position with an expectation that everyone in listening distance, dazzled by your brilliance, will immediately gravitate to it.

How rich is it that Russia who invaded Ukraine, claiming that it was, according to Putin, never an independent state, is reportedly circulating a resolution in the UN calling for a ceasefire in the war between the Israelis and Palestinians. I’m for a ceasefire immediately, but why is Russia, the invader and plunderer of Ukraine and Putin, the organizer of this bloody invasion, carrying the water here?

By the same token, one could argue that China and the other BRIC countries are guilty of a double standard as well. When it comes to Russia’s brutal, bloody, and illegal invasion of Ukraine they were and still are silent.

The current “precision” bombing of Gaza isn’t a ramp up to war, it is war. A planned ground invasion that could begin any day is a continuation and intensification of that war. Past time for a ceasefire!

With the settler movement encroaching more and more on land in the West Bank and the IDF planning to shrink Gaza of population and land space in the course of this one sided war, a two state solution would require a return to a status quo ante. Where that exactly is would be an issue of great contention. A one state solution is wishful thinking, I would say, detached from political realities and animosities on the ground. The resistance from both sides would make it completely impractical. Some will surely differ.