Last night’s debate

Bernie didn’t hit a home run and Biden didn’t strike out. On the pandemic, he outperformed Bernie. And generally speaking, this was Biden’s strongest debate and it is worth noting that he embraced some of the progressive positions of Bernie and Elizabeth Warren and committed to selecting a woman as his Vice Presidential running mate. He also announced that he would nominate a Black woman to the Supreme Court when a vacancy opens up. In the end, I doubt — and we’ll know soon — if the dynamics of the primary contest changed as a result of tonight’s debate. Advantage, and a big advantage at that, still rests with Biden. On Tuesday, we will know for sure, when some major states hold their primaries.

A socialist moment?

Is this a socialist moment, as some say? The short answer is no. Generally speaking, a political moment is determined by the particular alignment (or balance of power) between the working class and its allies on one side and its adversaries on the other and the political tasks that logically follow from that alignment.

So how does this apply to the present situation? Briefly, two powerful coalitions are at loggerheads. One is led by Trump and includes a motley collection of retrograde big, medium, and small sized capitalists, more than a sliver of white working people, white evangelicals, outright fascists, Fox and other right wing media outlets, and, not least, the entire Republican Party. The politics of this coalition are white nationalist, misogynist, xenophobic, homophobic, anti-working class, and relentlessly anti-democratic and authoritarian.

Vigorously opposing this toxic political bloc is a diverse people’s coalition. It includes sections of the working class and labor movement, people of color, a majority of women, most of the younger generation, and many others. Indeed, even some billionaires and millionaires from Wall Street and Main Street are in the mix.

The overarching task of this coalition is to defend our democracy from Trumpian onslaught in the midst of an exploding pandemic and an imploding economy. And there is no better terrain than this fall’s elections to do this. By denying Trump and his gang a second term to consolidate their power over the state, economy, and country and institutionalize one man dictatorial rule, space will be created to tackle climate disruption, systemic inequality, structural economic changes, pandemic diseases as well as save, expand, and deepen our democracy.

What then is the nature of the moment? It is, to the bone, a democratic one.

There is, for sure, a new, unprecedented interest in socialism. And no doubt, Bernie Sanders had a big hand in its popularization, particularly among young people. He broke the link in the public mind between socialism and its 20th century iteration and the repressive, authoritarian practices associated with it.

But, as significant as this is, it doesn’t make this moment a socialist one. It’s not the defining feature of the times in which we live. That designation belongs to the democratic struggle to break the steadily tightening and extraordinarily dangerous grip of right wing, authoritarian rule and breathe new life into our democracy and democratic institutions.

It behooves us not to confuse the two. When that happens, I can assure you, nothing good will come from it, as we are seeing in the negative, extreme, and sectarian reactions to the likely nomination of Joe Biden by many of Bernie’s supporters who believe, wrongly, that this is a “socialist moment.”

It’s never good to be rigid, but it isn’t helpful either to fail to understand the time of day. Such a failure, if embraced by too many people, will exact a steep price on Election Day.

Contradictory pressures

The containment and mitigation of the c-virus necessitates the workforce de-linking from work, while a functioning economy requires the opposite, that is, dynamic integration and close connections at the local, state, national, and global level. In the face of this contradiction, priority obviously goes to the former. Meanwhile, the mitigation of a contracting economy requires immediately a generous package of social insurance —- in other words, workers and their families should be paid in full to stay home — and other counter cyclical measures. To the credit of Nancy Pelosi, the House bill takes a big step in the provision of social insurance. And were it not for the Republicans, it would have been more generous. More funding, however, will be needed to meet the expanding scope of this crisis, which like all crisis hit unevenly. In other words, this interlocking crisis falls heaviest on people of color, women, and low income workers.

Full blow recession ahead?

Will the c-virus cause a recession? The economy will contract for sure even with counter cyclical measures and the provision of generous social insurance for working families and others reeling under the weight of this pandemic. But whether this contraction morphs into a full blown recession at the national and global level depends to a large extent on how effective national governments and international institutions are in simultaneously combating the pandemic and a contracting economy. Because our government — the most powerful and well endowed in the world — is led by an ignorant, dangerous, and America First narcissist and his team of dopes, it will make this difficult job all the more harder.

Fact based

Joe Biden is a safe choice for many people, but we should also bear in mind that the moderate lane in the Democratic presidential primary from the very beginning commanded more support from voters than the progressive-radical wing. A radical politics has to be fact based as well as radical.

Share This